Making the New Public Safety Safe
Shawn Fields’ The New Public Safety: Police Reform and the Lurking Threat to Civil Liberties, which will be published by the University of California Press in September, is a brave and wise effort to envision a post-DeFund the Police world. While the defund movement has, at best, been a mixed success, some municipalities have experimented with de-policing routine interactions with people who are unhoused and mentally ill, authorizing civilian “violence interrupters” to roam the streets, and handing over traffic enforcement to unarmed officials. In The New Public Safety, Fields endorses these developments but also cautions that, without regulation, they will become simply a new version of policing, one that may look “soft” but in fact is not. At the same time, he argues that, with regulation, soft policing is preferable to the goal of entirely dismantling government-oriented responses, a goal that is currently popular in some circles but, as Field shows, goes too far.
Chapters One and Two of the book summarize current policing disaggregation trends. These chapters are full of statistics and disturbing stories that demonstrate why it is a bad idea to have armed officials—trained in the use of force and charged with detecting and stopping crime—function as first responders for vulnerable people in trouble and as enforcers of low-level infractions. This part of the book also details how specialized agencies charged with handling specific types of crises, such as homelessness, psychiatric emergencies, and social service crises, can, in theory, do a better job than the police at promoting public safety. Chapter Two ends by describing the views of abolitionists, who aver that replacing police with other government officials will simply reintroduce today’s carceral and exploitative responses in a different form. While Fields recognizes that possibility, he disagrees with the abolitionists’ goal of eliminating both traditional and soft policing and outlines what needs to be done to avoid the outcomes they fear. Continue reading "Making the New Public Safety Safe"
